The property was first listed on Realtor.com on December 17 but received viral attention after appearing on the Instagram page Zillow Gone Wild — an account dedicated to unusual property listings in the US that has over 1.3 million followers.
The Instagram post, shared on December 20, had received over 94,000 likes at the time of writing.
Goodman told Insider he planned to paint only the shingle roof black but later committed to the color scheme throughout the house, with the help of local contractors.
"Although some may view it as dark, it is not once inside, given all of the natural light and overhead lighting," Goodman told Insider, adding that he was "absolutely not" a goth.
"It is simply a unique peaceful property, in my opinion," he added.
The property was originally built in 1993, Goodman said, adding that he was keen to keep its unique shape and build upon its quirkiness.
He said the neighbors were initially taken aback by the makeover but, for the most part, they were positively shocked: "It definitely cleaned up the overall appeal and gave everyone something to talk about."
Goodman said he believed the secluded location and large garage added to the mystery of the home.
"From the side street, all you can see is the three-car garage," he said, adding that passersby couldn't see enough of the house to figure out what the building is.
Its original design was quite "neutral and dated," Goodman said. It relied on a white and beige color scheme, with brown for the sides and roof.
Goodman told Insider that since the listing went live, the house has garnered a lot of worldwide interest thanks to its unique appearance.
He said: "Too many homes are the same — why not stand out or be different?"
The listing adds that the upper floor is equipped with a private tiled bath with "a double vanity," as well as a tiled walk-in shower.
"Sleek, sexy, and undeniably unique is this midwestern showstopper," the listing says.
"There's tons of natural light given that windows are all around on both floors, as well as the overhead skylights," he said.
The kitchen, bathrooms, and utility room all have white trim and charcoal-gray cabinetry. Goodman said he chose to add light to the space.
When asked if there were any limitations to the black house, he said: "None at all."
"If you love your sleep, there is no place more peaceful to do it," he said.
Goodman said the striking house would be "an absolute gem" for anyone looking for a relaxing home.
"It's easy to come and go and live in total peace and comfort," he added.
ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7o8HSoqWeq6Oeu7S1w56pZ5ufonyxtM6tpqxlkqGupLeMoaauq5Vitq24yKemoqtdq7azrctmnaiqXZy8tbTInGSlp5%2BgenN8kWpkamo%3D